Why is Turning Red so controversial?

Portrayals of Puberty and Teenage Realism

One of the biggest controversies comes from viewers seeing the movie as too mature, or inappropriate. Namely, this comes when Mei first transforms into the red panda, and her mom assumes she started her period – though the word is never actually spoken.

Why Turning Red is inappropriate?

What makes Turning Red inappropriate? Some parents have deemed the film's themes on puberty to be "too mature" for children. March 15, 2022 Updated: March 15, 2022 4:50 p.m. Pixar's new film "Turning Red" tackles the topics of puberty and periods.

Why are parents against Turning Red?

In addition to CinemaBlend's Sean O'Connell and New York pastor Mike Signorelli's infamous negative reviews of the film, “Turning Red” has also made some parents feel uncomfortable with their children being exposed to “adult topics like puberty and menstruation.”

Why were parents mad about Turning Red?

Parents are leaving negative reviews for Pixar's newest animated film "Turning Red," many complaining about the film's inclusion of themes such as puberty, saying the subjects are too mature for children. The 25th animated feature for Pixar hit the Disney + platform on March 11.

Is Turning Red a metaphor for periods?

When menstruation begins, it means major changes to the body. It comes along with unexpected hair growth, body odours, and seeing the colour red in… new places. And that's what Disney Pixar's Turning Red is all about!

Turning Red: Why Is Everyone So Mad?

Was Turning Red about periods?

While parents may be caught off guard by curious kids asking questions about puberty or periods after seeing the film, experts say the real issue is not talking about periods at all as well as the social stigma.

What is Turning Red a metaphor for?

In the Pixar animated feature "Turning Red," the protagonist Mei Lee transforms into a giant red panda each time she's overwhelmed by her emotions -- a metaphor for puberty.

Why do critics hate Turning Red?

The controversies, such as they are, range from claims that this film isn't relatable to insistent discomfort with the depiction of a young woman in puberty, a child having autonomy, and the very reality of — yes, sometimes cringeworthy — 13-year-old girls.

What is the panda a metaphor for in Turning Red?

In the movie, the main character Meilin turns into an oversized red panda whenever she feels strong anger or frustration. This occurrence is due to her ancestor's prayer of protecting her family in times of dire need, giving the women in her lineage the power to hone in this particular set of emotions.

Does Turning Red have inappropriate parts?

Turning Red is rated PG, which means that some material might not be suitable for younger kids. For example, it may contain suggestive dialogue, mild violence, very little sexual content and/or some inappropriate language. As a result, parental guidance is suggested.

What is the message in Turning Red?

Turning Red offers a timely message about female friendship, embracing change, and finding solutions to problems in mother-daughter relationships.

What is the moral of the story of Turning Red?

Emotions are To Be Processed, Not Suppressed

To everyone's surprise, Mei eventually learns to control her emotions and her red panda. This shows that even if we say that big feelings are normal and should be freely let out, we should also learn how to control them when needed.

What Disney Panda movie is about periods?

Disney's newest animated film, “Turning Red,” in which an adolescent girl contends with puberty, cultural expectations and her newfound tendency to turn into a giant red panda when overtaken by emotion, has viewers buzzing.

Is Disney's Turning Red inappropriate?

12+ In my opinion, the movie content is too mature for a younger crowd but okay for children who are aware of sex and periods. Not just a funny "human turns into an animal" movie.

Does red panda mean period?

“The red panda is a metaphor not just for puberty, but also what we inherit from our moms, and how we deal with the things that we inherit from them,” Shi tells Polygon. Turning Red is Shi's feature debut, a coming-of-age story following a Chinese-Canadian protagonist in the early 2000s.

What Disney cartoon is about periods?

Before Pixar's 'Turning Red,' 'Braceface' and a 1946 Disney Short Tackled the “Taboo” of Menstruation. Despite being decades apart, all three Disney-related projects grappled with backlash over tackling the topic onscreen.

What is the main conflict in Turning Red?

The central conflict in “Turning Red” is Mei Lin's anger toward her mother's efforts to prevent Mei Lin from learning about the family's maternal secret. This conflict reveals how crucial it is for parents to have conversations about growing up in the home.

What does the red panda symbolize?

Red Pandas' symbolic meaning

The red panda is a symbol of gentleness, compromise, and patience. Their spiritual meanings include balance, independence, security, as well as nonchalance. Furthermore, they also represent tree wisdom, tree divination, and recognizing the individual tree spirit.

Is Turning Red cringe?

The controversies, such as they are, range from claims that this film isn't relatable to insistent discomfort with the depiction of a young woman in puberty, a child having autonomy, and the very reality of — yes, sometimes cringeworthy — 13-year-old girls.

What did Billie Eilish did in Turning Red?

A To All The Boys star voices Robaire, the lead of 4*Town.

Is Turning Red about trauma?

Disney Pixar's animated movie, Turning Red tackles the sensitive topic of generational trauma in a creative storyline. The film follows Meilin “Mei” Lee. 13-year-old outgoing and diligent kid as she navigates through the chaotic stage of puberty and family secrets.

Is Turning Red about mental health?

And while Turning Red doesn't tackle the issue of mental health head on, and certainly doesn't allude to suicide in any way, it's evident throughout the film how both Mei and her mother suppress their feelings to maintain the status quo. That can lead to a drastic decline in mental health, Fullchange says.

Why is Turning Red so emotional?

The world of Turning Red is unabashedly women's. Everything said and done is by them, for them. At the core of it is also the repression that women and young girls face, the emotions they suppress, as well as the silence and obedience that daughters inherit form their mothers.

Is Turning Red about depression?

Bella Hadid's Story of Major Depression is All Too Relatable. In the last several years, so many celebrities have come out about their mental health issues that it's almost become cliché. Of course, it makes sense.

What was 4 town inspired by in Turning Red?

The fictitious 4*Town draws heavy inspiration from the real-life boy bands of the late-90s and early-2000s, more specifically, *NSYNC, Backstreet Boys, and, as the name suggests, possibly O-Town and B4-4 as well.