Who was a better general Lee or Grant?

Lee is considered the better commander. He scored huge victories up until Gettysburg in 1863, while fighting against bigger and better supplied troops.

Who was the better general in the Civil War?

Ulysses S Grant was the supreme Union general during the civil war and then later 18th President of the United States. Grant was instrumental in the battlefield defeat of the Confederacy and then as President worked to implement Reconstruction.

Why Grant was the better general?

Grant Was One of America's Most Brilliant Military Leaders. What he lacked in knowledge of military art and science, he made up for with tenacity and grit. What he lacked in knowledge of military art and science, he made up for with tenacity and grit. In March 1864, Ulysses S.

Who lost more soldiers Grant or Lee?

Appendices I and II facilitate a comparison of the casualty records of Grant and Lee. Lee's army incurred 55,280 more casualties than Grant's armies (208,922 versus 153,642). Lee's army imposed 49,562 more casualties on the enemy than Grant's armies imposed on their enemies (240,322 versus 190,760).

What advantage did Grant have over Lee?

While Robert E. Lee was strictly a Virginia-focused, one-theater commander who constantly sought reinforcements for his theater and resisted transfers to other theaters, Grant had a broad, national perspective, rarely requested additional troops from elsewhere, and uncomplainingly provided reinforcements to locations, ...

Civil War Talk: Grant or Lee?

Did Lee ever defeat Grant?

On May 8, 1864, Yankee troops arrive at Spotsylvania Court House, Virginia, to find the Rebels already there.

Who is the best US general of all time?

Did Grant accepted Lee's sword?

Despite romantic press accounts that spread after the war, Lee never offered his sword, and Grant, obviously, never refused it or returned it. In his memoirs, Grant wrote, “The much talked of surrendering of Lee's sword and my handing it back, this and much more that has been said about it is the purest romance.”

Who was General Lee rival?

NEXT, HISTORIANS JOHN MARSZALEK AND CRAIG SYMONDS LOOK AT THE MILITARY RIVALRY BETWEEN CIVIL WAR GENERALS ULYSSES S. GRANT AND ROBERT E. LEE, COMPARING. THE NEW YORK HISTORICAL SOCIETY HOSTED THIS HOUR-LONG DISCUSSION. ...

What caused Lee to surrender to Grant?

The Confederate Army's retreat moved southwest along the Richmond & Danville Railroad. Lee desperately sought a train loaded with supplies for his troops but encountered none. Grant, realizing that Lee's army was running out of options, sent a letter to Lee on April 7 requesting the Confederate general's surrender.

What were Ulysses S. Grant's weaknesses?

Grant was a natural leader with the temperament, intellect and disposition to lead men into battle. However, despite these towering strengths, he had one weakness that constantly threatened to ruin his career – alcohol.

What was Grant's greatest defeat?

Grant lost more than 18,000 men at Spotsylvania -- probably twice as many as Lee. Grant's next lunge toward Richmond resulted in one of the Union's worst defeats. At Cold Harbor, Virginia, on June 3, the Union once again smashed against Lee's defenses.

What was Robert E Lees weakness?

However, Robert E Lee Tactics proved fatally defective. His tactical defects were that he was too aggressive on the field, he frequently failed to take charge of the battlefield, his battle plans were too complex or simply ineffective, and his orders were too vague or discretionary.

Could Lee have won at Gettysburg?

Early extolled Lee's genius. In fact, Early claimed, Lee's Army of Northern Virginia would have won the Battle of Gettysburg, the turning point in the Civil War, if his orders had been obeyed.

Who was the most badass Civil War general?

TJ "Stonewall" Jackson

Jackson is often cited as being one of the most remarkable generals in Civil War history. This is namely due to his advanced tactics during warfare, his disdain for fighting on Sundays, and the fact that he was so tough he'd send his wife sappy love letters and no one even jostled him for it.

How good was Robert E. Lee as a general?

After his death in 1870, Lee became a cultural icon in the South and is largely hailed as one of the Civil War's greatest generals. As commander of the Army of Northern Virginia, he fought most of his battles against armies of significantly larger size, and managed to win many of them.

Who was Lee's most trusted general?

General James Longstreet- The most trusted of Lee's corps commanders, Longstreet's troops would bear the brunt of the fighting on July 2nd and July 3rd at Gettysburg. The general was in charge of the main Southern attack on the last day of the battle, even though he did not believe in its success.

What was Lee's greatest defeat?

Lee's Greatest Victory Lee's Greatest Defeat: the Battle of Chancellorsville.

Were Grant and Lee friends?

The two friends would finally meet again following the Confederate surrender at Appomattox Court House. It was Longstreet, according to various accounts, who persuaded Lee that Grant would offer generous terms there. When Grant did just that, the mood in the room was one of stiff relief.

Did Lee and Grant ever meet again?

The two men never met again. Lee died 17 months later. Lee is believed to be the only person to visit the White House after having their United States citizenship revoked. Copyright 2019 WWBT.

How many troops did Lee surrender to Grant?

In Appomattox, Virginia, on April 9, 1865, Robert E. Lee surrenders his 28,000 Confederate troops to Union General Ulysses S. Grant, effectively ending the American Civil War.

Who is the only 7 star general?

No person have ever been awarded or promoted to a seven-star rank, although some commentators might argue that General George Washington posthumously became a seven-star general in 1976 (see Part Seven).

Who is the only 6 star general?

Grant joins George Washington and John J. Pershing as the only generals to achieve the rank. This honor has been informally referred to as being a "six-star general." The highest official star rank in the U.S. Army is a five-star general, called the General of the Army.

Who Lee lost to?

With his Confederate army outnumbered and exhausted, General Robert E Lee finally surrendered to General Grant.