Which is better Hardie siding or stucco?

Hardie siding is warrantied up to 30 years, and it typically lasts much longer. Fiber cement is resistant to fire, mold, woodpeckers, insects, and rot. Perhaps the biggest benefit fiber cement has over stucco is that it resists moisture without wearing down or cracking.

Is Hardie siding worth the money?

James Hardie siding is a great, environmentally friendly choice for overall curb appeal and home value. It will give your home a new look and feel to it. It is an attractive choice with guaranteed durability and quality. It provides an amazing return on investment.

Which is better stucco or siding?

If you want durability, value, and style options, then siding is the best option for you. But, if you are not as concerned with budget and prefer a more natural seamless design look, go for stucco.

Is stucco more expensive than Hardie board siding?

Cost of Hardie Board vs Stucco

While stucco materials and labor averages $5.00 to $9.00 a square foot to install, Hardie board siding comes in at an average of $10.00 a square foot for materials and installation.

Is it cheaper to use stucco or siding?

The price of vinyl panels usually significantly varies, but even the most expensive ones cost less than stucco. Vinyl siding price ranges from a minimum of $6.5 to a maximum of $12.50 per installed 1 sq ft (0.09 m2). On the other hand, stucco will cost you an average of $14.50 per fully installed 1 sq ft (0.09 m2).

Advice on Hardie over stucco

Does stucco add value to a home?

Whether you're building a new home or simply renovating your existing one, stucco installation is something you should consider in your plans. Stucco is a durable and reliable siding material that can increase the value of your home.

Is cement board better than stucco?

Hardie siding is warrantied up to 30 years, and it typically lasts much longer. Fiber cement is resistant to fire, mold, woodpeckers, insects, and rot. Perhaps the biggest benefit fiber cement has over stucco is that it resists moisture without wearing down or cracking.

Does Hardie board Add R value?

While Hardie Board itself does not significantly increase your home's energy efficiency, it is compatible with insulating sheathing products, like the Fanfold insulation we use, which will boost your siding system's R-value.

Which is better stucco or cement?

Moisture. Fiber cement siding is the clear winner in terms of moisture proofing and water resistance. It's made to shed water, unlike dampness-prone stucco.

How long does stucco siding last?

Long-lasting:

Stucco can well last over 50 years with proper maintenance. It can expand and contract with the weather to sustain critical damage, unlike other siding options. It's also resistant to mold, rot and mildew.

What is the average labor cost to install Hardie siding?

Hardie Board siding materials cost $3 to $6 per square foot, and the labor cost to install is $3 to $7 per square foot. Old siding removal adds $0.25 to $1 per square foot when residing. Get free estimates from siding contractors near you or view our cost calculator below.

Is stucco a good choice?

Due to its brittle nature, stucco siding will crack if a house foundation settles. It simply isn't the best choice in regions where soil is high in clay, notorious for swelling and causing foundations to shift. Over time, even stucco on homes with firm foundations can develop hairline cracks.

Does Hardie board siding increase home value?

James Hardie siding will not only give your home a whole new look and feel; it will also significantly increase its value, as it has consistently been ranked one of the top projects with the highest return on investment by Remodeler Magazine's Cost vs. Value report.

What type of siding lasts the longest?

Vinyl siding is a popular choice when it comes to your home's cladding and actually lasts much longer than expected. With no effort or cleaning, it's expected to last you about 60 years but with meticulous care and maintenance, you can expect your vinyl siding to last up to 100 years.

Why is Hardie siding so expensive?

The installation process for fiber cement siding is longer and more expensive than the vinyl siding installation process. James Hardie fiber cement siding is heavy and requires specialized installation and an increased amount of labor.

Is Hardie plank siding tax deductible?

If the Hardie Board was installed on your personal residence, then the IRS will not allow a deduction for this new siding. However, you may be eligible for a Residential Energy Credit if you added insulation during the process of replacing your siding.

Does mold grow on Hardie board?

It is highly susceptible to mold and mildew. Hardie Plank has many seams and the seams must be sealed or water can infiltrate behind the siding. It can crack and if it does, you must tear the whole wall down in order to replace just one plank.

What is the most energy efficient siding?

Can you replace stucco with hardiplank?

One of the most common questions homeowners ask us is whether Hardie board can be installed over stucco, or if the stucco must always be removed. The short answer is that yes, we can install Hardie over stucco!

Should I replace stucco with siding?

When water damage and mold result from improper stucco application, it's time for a siding material change. The most popular siding replacement materials are fiber cement and vinyl. Vinyl may be cost-effective, but it is also thin, dents easily, and doesn't last as long as fiber cement.

What is the difference between hardiplank and Hardie board?

Fiber cement siding is often called “hardiplank” or even “hardie board” named from the most popular brand of fiber cement siding which is manufactured by James Hardie. Fiber cement planks are formed by combining wood pulp with Portland cement.

What are the disadvantages of stucco siding?

Should I avoid stucco homes?

Stucco can tolerate moisture and expansion only up to a certain point. It is not as good as brick veneer or vinyl siding for keeping water out of the exterior walls of your house during periods of heavy rain. It will repel water well in average climates, but it may not be recommended in extremely rainy areas.

Is it common for stucco to crack?

In short, hairline stucco cracks are common and can be easily repatched. Most are not a serious indicator of foundation damage or structural disrepair. However, hairline cracks caused by foundation settlement will likely reappear after the repair and worsen.