Does the golden rule work?

It provides a solution only if you can directly ask the other person precisely how they want to be treated — and if that option is available, you don't really need an overriding axiom to guide your behavior. This is why the Golden Rule is ultimately like every other maxim: It works flawlessly, until it doesn't.

What is one problem with the Golden Rule?

By modern philosophical standards, the golden rule is not commonly viewed as an adequate basis of moral theory. The problem with the rule “treat others as you would like to be treated” is that it does not, and cannot, distinguish between the 'good' and the 'bad' ways in which one might like to be treated.

How useful is the Golden Rule?

The Golden Rule can help you build consistency as a leader and as an organization. It helps you establish a standard of behavior and influence others to adhere to that standard in all situations and circumstances. This makes decisions about how to treat people in different situations easier.

What is a criticism of the Golden Rule?

Immanuel Kant famously criticized the golden rule for not being sensitive to differences of situation, noting that a prisoner duly convicted of a crime could appeal to the golden rule while asking the judge to release him, pointing out that the judge would not want anyone else to send him to prison, so he should not do ...

Why is the Golden Rule selfish?

The Golden Rule is used as a tool to direct the behavior of people towards an end that we assume is positive – if you want to be treated well, you should treat others well. But if we dig a bit deeper, we find that the Golden Rule is really selfish and not selfless. It is about ourselves.

The Trouble With The Golden Rule | Brendan Schulz | TEDxYorkU

Is the Golden Rule a fallacy?

It is a fallacy to assume the golden rule gives an infallible test of right and wrong that can be applied in seconds. The decision is likely to be wrong if the beliefs or assumptions used to make the decision are wrong. Consider these examples.

Does the Golden Rule still hold up?

It provides a solution only if you can directly ask the other person precisely how they want to be treated — and if that option is available, you don't really need an overriding axiom to guide your behavior. This is why the Golden Rule is ultimately like every other maxim: It works flawlessly, until it doesn't.

What is the number 1 golden rule?

1. Common Observations and Tradition. “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” This seems the most familiar version of the golden rule, highlighting its helpful and proactive gold standard.

What is better than the Golden Rule?

A potentially better rule is the “Platinum Rule” which states “Do unto others as they would want to be done to them.” This rule was developed by author Dave Kerpen. The great thing about the Platinum Rule is that it recognizes that everyone is different.

Is the Golden Rule an ethical test?

The 'Golden Rule' is probably the most well-known ethical code of all time, it encourages people to treat others the same way they would like to be treated themselves.

Do all religions believe in the Golden Rule?

The thing is that all major religions have the Golden Rule in Common. 'Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. ' Not always the same words but the same meaning.”

Why does Kant reject the Golden Rule?

Kant argued that the Golden Rule is inferior to this imperative: that since the Golden Rule does not contain principles of duties to one's own moral will, nor principles of “strict obligation to one another”, it could not be a universal law. (Groundwork For The Metaphysic Of Morals, 1785, p.

What is the platinum rule?

The Platinum Rule was popularized in Dr. Tony Alessandra's book of the same name. The Platinum Rule goes this way: “Treat others the way they want to be treated.” The Platinum Rule is a very subtle yet powerful and important shift from false consensus.

How is golden rule compared to karma?

According to the 'golden rule', we are not only supposed to do good because we are afraid that Karma will catch up with us but we must do good because it is the right thing to do. Serve others exactly the same way you would like to be served.

What is the diamond rule?

The Diamond Rule — The Golden Rule and the Platinum Rule may not be sufficient in all situations. So, the Diamond Rule is, “treat others the way they don't even know they want to be treated.” To boil it down … anticipate, anticipate, anticipate. Don't just meet expectations, EXCEED them.

What are the 3 rules in life?

What is the Golden Rule for yourself?

Self-compassion is applying the golden rule to yourself. It is to treat yourself in a way that you treat others. It is to respect, love, protect, and care for yourself each and every day. It is to let go of judgment and criticism and replace it with patience and gratitude.

How do you practice the Golden Rule?

What is the platinum rule vs golden rule?

The golden rule is to do unto others as you'd have them do unto you; the platinum rule is to do unto others as they'd want done unto them. In other words, reject reciprocity as an ideal, in favor of something like empathy.

What is the new version of the Golden Rule?

It's time to adopt a “New Golden Rule:” Treat others as they would like to be treated. It's a small change, but one that can make a huge difference. All it takes to put this new mindset into practice is understanding, curiosity, and compromise.

Is the Golden Rule a value or belief?

This belief appears in some form across many religions and philosophies, and it has been included as a fundamental moral value of some governments and the basis for many laws. The actual term “Golden Rule" or “Golden Law" has been used since the late 17^th century.

Is the Golden Rule a universal truth?

It is something that all people, regardless of what else they believe, can agree on. Indeed, the best-known expression of the principle of respect – the Golden Rule – can be found in religions and traditions all over the world.”

What is pooh pooh fallacy?

A pooh-pooh (also styled as poo-poo) is a fallacy in informal logic that consists of dismissing an argument as being unworthy of serious consideration. Scholars generally characterize the fallacy as a rhetorical device in which the speaker ridicules an argument without responding to the substance of the argument.

What is the opposite of the golden rule?

It is a reversal, or the opposite, of the Golden rule. It says, “Don't do unto others what you would not want done unto you.” Sometimes it's what we don't do that are just as important, if not even more so, than the do's.

Is there a silver rule?

The Silver Rule is basically the “Negative” Golden Rule. Taleb writes it as follows: “Do not treat others the way you would not like them to treat you.” Stated another way: if you don't want “X” done to you, don't do “X” to someone else.